The DOT Framework

From ICT research methods
Jump to: navigation, search
Category:WorkshopCategory:FieldCategory:LibraryCategory:LabCategory:ShowroomDOT-Framework.jpg

Research in ICT

As a bachelor of ICT, your research aims at creating an ICT product which fits it needs (in this context an ICT product can be a software product, or an ICT design or advise/report). The research is focused on the product, and not per se on creating new knowledge which is the aim in most scientific research.

To give you a glimpse of possible ICT research:

  • investigating the stakeholders' wishes
  • choosing the most appropriate technology for a (part of) ICT system
  • investigating the usefulness of a certain technology or framework
  • testing the quality of an ICT product

The Development Oriented Triangulation Framework

To help you in your ICT research, we advise the use of the Development Oriented Triangulation (DOT) framework ([1]). The DOT framework can help you to structure your research and to communicate about it. The Development Oriented Triangulation (DOT) framework consists of three levels:

  • The "What" of your research (the domains)
  • The "Why"of your reserach (the trade-offs)
  • The "How" of your research (the strategies and methods)

All three levels are visualized in the DOT Framework overview at the top-right of this page.

Three Domains.jpg

The "What"of your research (the domains)

You can research both the specific application context of your project and the more general knowledge available that can help your project. Both types of research will help you, and are necessary to create your own "innovation", your new product/advice/report. We can express this by three domains. The first domain is the "application domain". This is the domain of the specific context that the ICT project takes place. The second domain is of "available work". All available theory, models and other artefacts that you can use are part of the available work domain. Thirdly is the "innovation domain", where your actual innovation takes place and all of the research is done.

The "Why" of your research

Explaining what you want to obtain with your research will help you to better structure your research. If you do research in the application context your reason for research will probably be to obtain a product which is relevant for the stakeholders. You are trying to optimise the fit between your product and the application context. Oftentimes you want to assure that your product is up to contemporary quality standards. In those cases you want to use all the expertise available to create your product. You do this by doing research in the "available work" domain. As there are few methods that simultaneously optimise fit and expertise it is often needed to combine both types of methods in the project.

Similarly there is a tradeoff between optimising overview and certainty. Often, mostly in the beginning you want to gain a good overview over what is needed or what is available. At other times you want to test specific aspects of your work, making sure it works. In these cases you try to configure your research to optimise "certainty" about your hypotheses or goals.

Lastly, in most cases your research might require a data oriented approach to justify your choices, prove completeness and so on. Sometimes, however, it is a good idea to choose a more inspiration based method, like the Brainstorm method.

The "How" of your research (the strategies and methods)

So during a project you try to learn as much as you can about the context of available work, the application context and the innovation space. What are ways of learning these things? The DOT-Framework has 5 research strategies.

Library
Logo-library.png

Library research is done to explore what is already done and what guidelines and theories exist that could help you further your design. Since the advent of the internet library research is also called desk research.

Field
Logo-field.png

Field research is done to explore the application context. You apply a field strategy to get to know your end users, their needs, desires and limitations as organizational and physical contexts in which they will use your product.

Lab
Logo-lab.png

Lab research is done to test parts or concepts of your product, of the final product. You use lab research to learn if things work out the way you intended them, or to test different scenarios.

Showroom
Logo-showroom.png

Showroom research is done to test your ideas in relation to existing work. Showing your prototype to experts can be a form of showroom research or spelling out how your product is different from the competition. Also testing your product to general guidelines is a form of showroom research.

Workshop
Logo-workshop.png

Workshop research is done to explore opportunities. Prototyping, designing and co-creation activities are all ways to gain insights in what is possible and how things could work.

For each of the strategies, decide on the research method that best fits the need that you want to do. The method that you choose depends on your specfic research question and the ICT field. Each field has its own methods, from which the most important are listed here: Methods.

DesignPatternExampleForMixedMethods.jpg

Triangulation

Most projects require a mix of methods to get answers to your research questions. In most cases, both "fit" and "expertise" are of importance, and the same holds for "overview" and "certainty". Therefore, combining the appropriate methods to cover for the different views is important. Combining methods with opposing goals is sometimes called "method triangulation". Some of the more common combinations of methods have been defined as design patterns.